Thursday, April 14, 2011
Now, gods, stand up for bastards!
Edmunds speech act I scene 2 reminds me alot of Shylock and his "Hath a jew not eyes?" speech. They both are from the antagonist, both decry the stigma their society places on them becuse of their respective status' and garner sympathy from the audience. The main difference is Shylock's speech is about how christians and jews are the same while Edmund's is about how he is better then what most people think of him. This makes it less a cry for equality and more a cry for recognition. At the start of the play Edmunds father makes harsh jokes at his(Edmunds) expense. This, in addition to the knowlege that he shal recive nothing upon his fathers deah justifies Edmunds actions to himself, but not the audience I feel, especially when you factor in Edgar, who is nothing but nice to Edmund and who is royaly screwed buy Edmunds plan. At the end of the speech Edmund says "Now, gods, stand up for bastards!" but I feel this is insincere. He doen't care about society and it laws mistreating bastards, he is angry about the laws mistreating him, he couldn't care less about others in his sithuation.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
2 comments:
I agree that there's something a bit insincere about Edmund's objections. Whereas Shylock really garners a bit of authentic sympathy, the way Edmund deals with it is really kind of petty and selfish leaves me with a bad impression. It's a complex thing when someone with the right message, and who is rightly angry about the injustices put upon him, handles it in such a wrong way.
Thanks for swinging us back to Merchant of Venice, Chris. And I like how your post points to Edmund's character wicked irony vis-a-vis Shylock's more pure intentions. Wouldn't it be great in some alter-Shakespearean world to see (ha!) or perhaps more appropriately Lear-ian "hear" these two duke it out? ;)
Post a Comment