Monday, November 8, 2010

The Promise Amongst Men

Before I start my blog I would like to say that this is my first time ever reading Hamlet since I know most people have, so what I write is only based on what I know from act 1. So anyway for my blog this week I would like to talk about the promise that Horatio and Marcellus made to Hamlet the night he met with the ghost. During this scene Hamlet meets the ghost of his father and find out the true villain and reason for his passing is Hamlet’s own uncle and Father’s brother. This is the first moment when the characters on the play find out what really happened to the King. Hamlet finding out about his father’s death comes to the realization that he must revenge his father, but he must first make sure no one knows of what has taken place that night. Besides Hamlet the other two people who witnessed Hamlet’s discussion with his dead father were Horatio and Marcellus who are not only night guards, but are also considered friends to Hamlet. When Hamlet realizes that he must keep this meeting a secret he has these two men swear on his sword that they will never tell anyone about what happened that night no matter what. Whether Hamlet acts as mad as a hatter they are told to never say they knew that Hamlet was acting strange or if they saw it coming. I believe this is very important to the play for various reasons. First of all the burden that these men have to keep their mouths shut may become very tough as they may not believe Hamlet and worry for the protection of the new King. If the swear is broken by these men then Hamlet’s plot of revenge may fail as well. This swear is also important because if these two men are the only ones who know the truth about Hamlet’s father’s death then they may be the only two people who can help Hamlet achieve his revenge. These two men have made a promise of the sword of Hamlet and their promise is very important to the plot of the play as their actions can change what happens more so than any other character at this point in the play. What purpose they do serve is a mystery to me right now, however I am curious what does become of these two and will their sighting of the ghost every night be an omen of their own future deaths? I guess I will have to read on to find out.

3 comments:

Kaitlin Clifford said...

I agree and also think that the promise that Haratio and Marcellus make, swearing on his sword to not speak of what they witnessed, is very important to the play. I haven’t read this play before either and I’m predicting that this will have something to do with the tragedy of Hamlet. I didn’t realize the importance of these two men until I read your post and I am very curious to see how it is going to play out and what role they will have and if they will stand by their promise or if they will crack sending things into a downward spiral. It also never crossed my mind if the sighing of the ghost every night will be an omen of their (Horaito and Marcellus) deaths. Is their promise to Hamlet going to be enough, will they be able to stand by their word? For some reason, I want to say no, just because it is a tragedy.

Holly Langan said...

What a great post! This is the first time I am reading Hamlet as well so it is all new to me! I definitley think that Horatio and Marcellus are not going to keep their promise to Hamlet and things are going to turn really ugly, hence why it is a tragedy. There has to be some type of problem that is caused by mistrust of the characters. Are they really friends of Hamlet or no? I agree with you, this is very important!! Because this scene may be the reason why later events occur in the play. I think Hamlet would have been better off if no one else witnessed this conversation he had and it was his own secret. You really can't trust anybody, that's for sure!!

Cyrus Mulready said...

I hadn't thought of it before, but this post definitely sets up some really important ideas in the play. Claudius's betrayal of his brother, Rosencrantz and Guildenstern's duplicity with Hamlet, Claudius's deceit with Hamlet...all things we see over the course of this play. It also makes the final moment between Laertes and Hamlet more meaningful--I won't spoil anything about the ending, though!!